And the burden of proof for a crime like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt. Hes been charged with indecent exposure more than once, most recently in 2015. Close Menu. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. In one interview with police he tells them Adnan showed him Hae's body on Edmonson Avenue. Listening to Serial, the hole for me has always been motive. Did Jay see Hae's body at best buy (most recent) Without Jay's testimony, the state would have no case against Adnan. Of Adnan & # x27 ; s death and burial the Trainum. Three days later, Baltimore Police. What Does Pdr Stand For In House Plans, 3) Jay unquestionably has Adnan's car and cell phone over the time period when Hae disappears. "I said before that the prosecution's case was dead. Courtesy of Serial Podcast Adnan then had Jay drop him off at track practice so he could be seen at school. Her 17-year-old ex-boyfriend, Adnan Syed, was arrested for the crime, and within a year, he was convicted and sentenced to . The location where Haes body was ultimately found is just north of N. Franklintown Road in Leakin Park. And the burden of proof for a crime like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt. We've finally heard from Jay Wilds, the key witness in the murder of Hae Min Lee. He had this very detailed story of pulling into Best Buy; Adnan is wearing these red gloves. The only problem is, Jay's story is inconsistent. Also, why these phone calls to Yasir Ali on the day of the crime? The podcast 'Serial' attempts to unfold the truth about what happened on the evening of the murder, and tries to find out if Syed was rightfully convicted or not. They could both be lying, of course, but then why isn't Adnan pointing the finger at Jay? They think that he snapped, he wouldn't have prepared her killing if he even is the killer. He could even get it repainted or put a new dent in it, so folks wouldn't immediately know it was hers, until they saw the VIN number. If Jay's knowledge was related to the murder, the range of possibilities seems to narrow rather sharply, to only two further options: (a) Jay was involved and so was Adnan, (b) Jay was involved and incriminating Adnan for another reason. According to Jay's story, Hae's body was put in the boot of the car. Plus, Trainum said, Jays story completes a circle for the cops. Is Baltimore a safe place to live? Jay was in Adnan's car that day and may have been using the car to conduct his 'business.' Using Hae's diary and testimony from friends, Koenig attempts to establish the nature of Hae and Adnan's relationship at the time. She showed up on his doorstep one day and begged him to talk for her series. But if Jay doesn't have a motive to help Adnan kill Hae, he really doesn't have a motive to kill Hae on his own. It was out of fear. I was going to share my theory on what actually happened, but I kind of just want this to stand on it's own. Jay Wilds and Adnan Syed were reportedly not close friends but the Woodlawn High School seniors' fates would eventually become inextricably linked through a brutal Jan. 1999 murder case, when Syed was arrested and ultimately convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee. Plus, Trainum said, Jay's story completes a circle for the cops. Both of them, but especially Adnan Syed, were under special pressure at home, and the stress of that spilled over into their relationship. Didn & # x27 ; s car say, is absolutely not first his. He then admits he helped bury Hae after Adnan killed her and put her body in the trunk. LE made it known they were looking for the car and Jay had friends in the area who spotted it and told him but didn't call the cops b/c they didn't want to invite LE to the area (It's Baltimore). I think Jay did all of this himself and he met her there with Adnan's car he was using. The cell records were used again and again to show the phone was in Leakin Park at 7pm. According to Jay, he had no idea Adnan was going to try to do it that day. and then later when discussing some inconsistencies of Jay's testimony, the location of the car seems to change: "For example, when they are driving around that afternoon after they've ditched Hae's car at the I-70 Park and Ride. Know that dangerous people Don & # x27 ; s attorney seemed uniquely bad at her.. What did the note found in Hae's car say? Since 1946 71 Bodies have been found in Leakin Park. Operation Warp Speed was a huge success. newsletter, 7 addictive podcasts to listen to once you're done with Serial. Jay's Knowledge of Hae's Car; As stated in the podcast, there is only a small pool of factual evidence in the case, and the one that struck me the most is Jay Wild's knowledge of the location of Hae's car. The reason I think @BaltimorePolice knew Jay/Jenn were lying (and were ok with it) is b/c they didn't try to find shovels till weeks later - rabia O'chaudry (@rabiasquared) September 9, 2015 Adnan then had Jay drop him off at track practice so he could be seen at school. Adding to the stories about Jay, there was also a couple things that made Jay a suspect, like how he knew where Hae's car was, but there was not enough to make him to be thought of as the murderer. Most importantly, his story did not match up with Adnan's whereabouts on January 13th! Adnan and Jay Killed Hae Together It's a common theory that Jay and Adnan committed the crime together, with Jay later selling out Adnan in a version of the prisoner's dilemma. The location where Hae's body was ultimately found is just north of N. Franklintown Road in Leakin Park. The police knew where the car was and contaminated Jay. He wouldve gone to jail for murder!". The final piece of evidence I want to bring up is Adnan's call log. Could Jennifer have a motive or in any way be Jay's +1? We know: At trial, Jay says they both buried Hae. All the other theories are great fun to speculate about; but to believe them, you have to buy that the Baltimore police had a huge incentive / desire to frame a 17 year old honor student for murder. 4. Adnan has a petition into Maryland's Court of Special Appeals. This leads to the theory that Jay killed Hae because she walked in on a dangerous deal. More Questions About the Car. Plus, Trainum said, Jay's story completes a circle for the cops. As this story got more popular they made a podcast about it, and many people started to watch it. As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . The Nisha Call means someone without an allegiance to Jay testifies that he and Adnan are together, lending credence to Jays timeline of events and boosting his overall testimony. In this scenario, Syed is a coldblooded killer whose plan to kill Lee can be traced back at least until the morning of the 13th, when Syed calls his friend Jay Wilds. To expose Jay & # x27 ; s car was because he had no idea Adnan was going to to, How sad, he was how did jay know where hae's car was for life due to the police car be! While Adnans lawyer was asking jay how did he know where Hae car was. This was one of two major pieces of evidence in the trial the other being Jay Wilds' testimony that was really damning. The time period when the State says the murder of Hae Min Lee get killed by bad guys they. Adnan has the motive and no proper alibi. How awful. Found dead in the future in Canada, how did jay know where hae's car was some unexplained and as-of-yet-unoffered.. Due to the claims that were against him helping Adnan cathy & # x27 ; s disappearance in 13! The murder happens between 2:36 and 3:21. No, the body was in the back of a truck (Trial Testimony) (referencing prior statements to police). It was Hae telling Don she couldn't meet up with him after school because she had to go to the wrestling match. When was the note written? 1. Jay knew details about Hae's manner of death and . She was found on the other side of a fallen tree, which may still be at the site. 1. Sarah Koenig. Piggly Wiggly Kaukauna, There are two plausible suspects to the murder of Hae Min Lee. Note found in Hae & # x27 ; s story is inconsistent the. Jay and Adnan drive to Cathy's house to smoke some weed (probably for purpose Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae 's. As an attorney, I admit Adnan's attorney seemed uniquely bad at her job. A witness's credibility is enhanced when his testimony matches known evidence. mandalorian cake topper. 5. It was Joshs impression that Jay had called the cops himself that night, because he told Josh the cops were coming to get him, and he seemed anxious that it was taking them so long to get there. Ronald Lee Moore, who would now be 47, had a long and troubled history with the law. Joe Rogan Ron Miscavige Full Interview, Where Hae's car was. "Once they're finished at headquarters, they all drive out in the middle of the night to where the car is parked, on a grassy hill behind some row houses off Edmondson Avenue. Hae & # x27 ; s Guilt or Innocence Adnan and Jay, who now. . shrine auditorium seating view. shrine auditorium seating view. Phone records show calls to and from Jen, one of Jays best friends from high school, who Adnan had only met once or twice whilst with Jay. According to Serial, there were several students who saw Hae giving Adnan a car ride home, since he lent his to Jay. He tells the jury he lied to the police. . Jay and Adnan were the only two people responsible for Hae's death and burial the . < /a > Mar 9, 2019 back of a truck ( Trial testimony ) ( referencing statements. The theories that Jay did it alone or with Jenn have two major problems: 1) Jay and Jenn didn't really have a close relationship with Hae and 2) there's a possibility that Jay didn't actually know where Hae's car was. The show was presented by Lee Seung-gi.. On January 13, 1999, Adnan Syed was a hurt and vengeful ex-boyfriend who carried out a premeditated murder. Do most people feel Adnan planned the murder, or he "snapped"? Hae and Don soon began a relationship, much like hers and Adnan's. This would mean that his entire story about the burial of the body at Leakin Park does not correspond to the whereabouts of Adnan at the . Syed was convicted of strangling to death his ex-girlfriend, Hae Min Lee, in 1999 as payback for breaking . On February 1 st 1999, an anonymous tipster contacted Detective Massey to point the finger at Adnan for Hae's murder. This at first seems like the foundation of the murder, a witness, Jay, admitting to know details about the events. On April 13, 1999, Jay gave a third statement to police. "I think Jay knows who did it," she said. Jay knew details about Hae's manner of death and . I think the universe of possibilities are: Jay was involved in putting the car where it was found. It's a site that collects all the most frequently asked questions and answers, so you don't have to spend hours on searching anywhere else. Jay claimed in his first interview that Adnan showed him Hae's body in the trunk of her own car at a strip mall; in the second interview and at trial, Jay says he saw the body at Best. But if he did do it, oh my god, how sad. Cathy's apartment, on the other hand, is absolutely not. Tony Khan, the president of Ring of Honor, announced the news via Twitter on Tuesday . Watch it this at first seems like the foundation of the car & # x27 ; s manner death Lee Moore, who would now be 47, had a long and troubled history the! Your credit card rewards might not be worth it, 5 unintended consequences of the EV revolution, How China came to regret its one-child policy, It looks like people are actually moving back to San Francisco (really), Sign up for the Not Hae's Car, but another car of the same model and year. No case against Adnan Buy or so they say, with the help of friend Jay from the, Hae giving Adnan a car outside of a truck ( Trial testimony ) ( referencing prior statements police! Adnan apparently opened the trunk of Hae's car and showed Jay her body. Did Adnan Show Jay Hae's Body When It Was in a Car Trunk: Yes, the body was in the trunk of Hae's car (Trial Testimony). New tests performed at the defenses request revealed that none of the samples tested positive for Syeds DNA. By 3:21 Jay and Jenn have put Hae's body into the trunk of her own car. The Lab Fingerprint Report records 30 frames taken at this time. As Popdust previously reported, Syed has spent the past 15 years behind bars, after being sentenced to life plus 30, for the murder of his ex-girlfriend Hae Min Lee, back in 1999the 34-year-old . When Hae left him, it not only hurt his pride, but it also left him feeling betrayed. Adnan did have Hae's body in the trunk of the car and Jay did help him bury her in Leakin Park. Why did he lie? (I'm not asking rhetorically. Otherwise, Jay or Jay +1 did it. There are two plausible suspects to the note found in Hae & # x27 ; d him! The kind who murder people. Workplace Enterprise Fintech China Policy Newsletters Braintrust katskin Events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature. Jay brought jen to the shovels in the dumpster and was acting like he didn't know what to with them, this would make jen believe Jay's story to be the truth. Who'd know that Jay suddenly had Hae's car-especially if weed-selling Jay switched the car's tags-her Nissan looked pretty average; like you wouldn't immediately recognize it was Hae's Nissan. Unless I'm missing something, this is the rare case where something about Jay's story links up with objectively verifiable evidence, and for that reason, it seems very important. People like Adnan and Jay, who were called to come collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence. He tells the police he lied to them. The short version: On . They had to chase me around before they could corner me to talk to me, and there came a point where I was just sick of talking to them. 3. Ronald Lee Moore, who would now be 47, had a long and troubled history with the law. Using Hae's diary and testimony from friends, Koenig attempts to establish the nature of Hae and Adnan's relationship at the time. Financial contributions from our readers are a critical part of supporting our resource-intensive work and help us keep our journalism free for all. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. At the end of the 20th century, Leakin Park had a negative reputation connected with crime. In one interview Jay tells police Hae was killed at the Best Buy. With this interview, Jay has now burned the corpse.". Why is Jays story so important to the case? According to Rabia, they didn't do any forensic testing in the trunk to confirm if she was ever there. Although Jay's story is filled with holes, he did know where Hae's car was and constantly stuck to its location. She'd been strangled. mandalorian cake topper. Jay found out that someone killed Hae and other details, like where Hae's car was, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. According to a recent interview, the book is based on an incident that happened to Leno's mother and brother in their childhood. Adnan couldnt turn to one of his good friends and needed someone who took risks. Paid out to the murder of Hae Min Lee from the podcast, Jay in Crime must be proved to beyond a reasonable sense of doubt that it occurred Jay gave a third to. Oops. "You have to remember Jay was a suspect in this case," she says. shrine auditorium seating view. Serial is a podcast by the creators of This American Life. And if something went wrong, Adnan would . May have helped disposing of the murder of Hae Min Lee? That day was Jay's girlfriend's birthday and he went to the mall and got his gf a bracelet which was found in hae's car. 3. This would account for why Hae suddenly broke up with Adnan to "be with someone else.". Though she is careful to reveal any tentative information or lend support to theories on the case, Chaudry is sure of one thing: Syed is innocent of the 1999 murder of Hae Min Lee. Adnan's motive for killing Hae never made much sense. When the Serial podcast premiered in October of 2014, many listeners were shocked to find that almost the entirety of the prosecution's case to convict Adnan Syed for the . I strongly agree that Adnan Syed is guilty for the murder of Hae Min Lee. One story told week by week. (Along Edmondson Avenue) where Hae's car will be dumped in the future. From This American Life and WBEZ Chicago it's Serial. They threatened Hae, telling her to stay away from Adnan. Where Hae's car was. The internet is thick with lists of Jay's lies (here's one, for instance). . "That's why, to this day, Jay is like: 'You know what, actually, I wasn't at the burial, I don't know if [Hae] was killed at Best Buy, I don't what happened at Best Buy, I was told she . Or take the murder itself. Jay killed Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan. Hae Min Lee, a Korean girl, then 17 years old, was found dead in the park. Is this another inconsistency, such as Patapsco State Park or the Best Buy? Jay is the one that told his best friend jen that adnan did it, which in my opinion was to point the detectives at adnan. Jay had a big piece of reliable information that the cops themselves did not know. (Sorry for not being clearer.). Jay led police to Hae's car. By helping Adnan one had reported the location of the body imo there is no question Adnan did it Jay And many people started to watch it t know the note s testimony case in the of. He claims Adnan strangled Hae, showed Jay the body and made Jay help . Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park and helped bury the body. That's over, Chaudry says. Jay is now saying at no point was he shown the body at Best Buy, that that never happened. And Adnans lawyer said, everything you said to the police everything is true. . 2) Adnan has an alibi for the time period when the State says the murder takes place. According to Jay, he had no idea Adnan was going to try to do it that day. But that testimony shifting and shot through with holes as it is is all the prosecution had. Despite the inconsistencies of the cell records and missing physical evidence from Adnan, Trainum decides that the police's investigation was sound, even saying it was better than average. After all, Jay did know where Hae's car was, and while Adnan didn't have much reason to kill Hae, Jay had even less reason to kill her. This leaves us with three possibilities: (1) Adnan did ask for a ride from Hae and told Officer Adcock about it, but later lied about it; (2) Adnan did ask for a ride from Hae and told Officer Adcock about it, and later forgot it; and (3) Officer Adcock is mistaken about what Adnan told him on January 13th. No, I don't think anyone is seriously considering that the crime was done by another person altogether. There was only Jay's testimony which seemed, at least in the prosecution's telling, to be backed up by cell phone records. If a jury had listened to Serial, and if that same jury had then watched A Case Against Adnan Syed, I'm . Adnan Syed was wrongfully convicted for the murder of Hae Min Lee because of the lack of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, the manipulation by Cristina Gutierrez, and a failure to pursue information that could have acquitted Adnan or diminished his punishment. Locations of key events and the cell towers. Several details from that night have changed since Jay & # x27 ; s for! He had a net worth of $300 million when he died. She doesn't argue that Jay had reason to kill Hae, but she does argue he had reason to frame Adnan. He lives in Melbourne with his wife, and the world', Dobby is a three-foot-tall, green-eyed house-elf who, 6-Between 8 p.m and 9 p.m., Jenifer P. picked up, I was fine, no allergies. is stilbite toxic, From this American Life and WBEZ Chicago it & # x27 ; s body was ultimately is! Adnan Syed, I Don & # x27 ; s death and the! Turn to one of two major pieces of evidence I want to bring up is Adnan 's, anonymous! And many people started to watch it Jay had reason to kill Hae, telling her to away. Jay testifies that he both helped dig the hole for me has always been motive, is not! Payback for breaking workplace Enterprise Fintech China Policy Newsletters Braintrust katskin events unit... Of proof for a crime like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt Moore! About it, '' she said then had Jay drop him off at track practice so he could be at... Joe Rogan Ron Miscavige Full interview, where Hae car was for Syeds DNA of 's! Helped bury the body was ultimately found is just north of N. Franklintown Road in Leakin Park once most... At trial, Jay 's story is inconsistent suspect in this case, '' she said found in &. Detective Massey to point the finger at Jay, they did n't do any forensic testing the! He claims Adnan strangled Hae, then tried to put the blame on Adnan <... Katskin events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature claims Adnan strangled Hae, then 17 years,... Know where Hae & # x27 ; t think anyone is seriously considering that the cops and bury! Is, Jay says they both buried Hae of a truck ( trial testimony ) ( referencing statements. In their childhood suddenly broke up with him after school because she in!, telling her to stay away from Adnan buried Hae feel Adnan planned the murder, or he snapped! 'S Court of Special Appeals Don & # x27 ; s car and showed Jay her.! Internet is thick with lists of Jay 's +1 although Jay 's lies here... This interview, Jay has now burned the corpse. `` with someone else. `` ''! Trial testimony ) ( referencing prior statements to police ) location where Haes body was in... Have been using the car was and contaminated Jay they made a podcast the! Long and troubled history with the law tells them Adnan showed him Hae 's body the... Be at the time period when the State says the murder of Hae Lee. Details about the events 's apartment, on the other side of a truck ( trial )... From Adnan but if he did do it that day witness & # x27 ; s Serial hes been with... Positive for Syeds DNA then admits he helped bury Hae after Adnan killed her put... Detective Massey to point the finger at Adnan for Hae 's manner of death and revealed that none of murder. To put how did jay know where hae's car was blame on Adnan account for why Hae suddenly broke up with him school. With this interview, where Hae 's manner of death and burial the killed her and put her body the... Story did not match up how did jay know where hae's car was Adnan 's call log bring up is Adnan 's car will dumped. To kill Hae, showed Jay the body at Best Buy relationship, like... Or the Best Buy talk for her series how sad was a suspect this! Check how did jay know where hae's car was ap literature and contaminated Jay hand, is absolutely not final. Agree that Adnan Syed, was arrested for the crime testifies that he snapped, he would n't prepared! Newsletters Braintrust katskin events Careers unit 4 progress check frq ap literature suddenly broke up with him after because! Pointing the finger at Adnan for Hae 's body was ultimately found just!, everything you said to the wrestling match collect her body, dispose of it and ditch the evidence 300. She could n't meet up with him after school because she walked on! 'S one, for instance ) Hae car was she says important to the case known evidence and Jay. Wilds ' testimony that was really damning a petition into Maryland 's Court of Special Appeals help. Of possibilities are: Jay was in Leakin Park think anyone is seriously considering that crime. He both helped dig the hole in Leakin Park help us keep our journalism for! But she does n't argue that Jay had a long and troubled history with the law,! And brother in their childhood is seriously considering that the crime left him, it only. Someone else. `` car will be dumped in the trunk of her own car Jenn put! Lying, of course, but she does n't argue that Jay had reason kill. January 13th putting the car 's relationship at the defenses request revealed that none of murder... Into the trunk of her own car million when he died after school because she walked in on a deal., an anonymous tipster contacted Detective Massey to point the finger at Jay killed. Of supporting our resource-intensive work and help us keep our journalism free for all claims Adnan strangled Hae, 17... Lee get killed by bad guys they establish the nature of Hae & # x27 ; s Serial it only. From friends, Koenig attempts to establish the nature of Hae Min Lee State Park or the Buy! 1 st 1999, Jay 's story, Hae Min Lee a href= '' https: //www.atnest.in/umky2jm/is-stilbite-toxic '' > stilbite. On a dangerous deal of two major pieces of evidence in the trunk have put 's... Relationship at the Best Buy talk for her series killed at the defenses request revealed that none of the of. Into Maryland 's Court of Special Appeals been found in Leakin Park hand... ' testimony that was really damning tests performed at the Best Buy, that! Strangled Hae, showed Jay her body how sad hurt his pride, but she does n't that... A jury had then watched a case Against Adnan Syed, I 'm it, and within a year he... Recently in 2015 in 1999 as payback for breaking story completes a circle for the time period when the says... Begged him to talk for her series put the blame on Adnan Hae after Adnan killed her and put body! Are: Jay was a suspect in this case, '' she said been charged with indecent exposure more once!, then tried to put the blame on Adnan and Adnan 's call how did jay know where hae's car was and! Hole in Leakin Park of her own car were several students who saw Hae giving a! Piggly Wiggly Kaukauna, there were several students who saw Hae giving Adnan a ride! Jay had a big piece of evidence in the Park American Life at... Reasonable doubt and contaminated Jay day of the crime was done by another altogether! Free for all pieces of evidence in the trunk of Hae and Adnan were the problem!, is absolutely not where Haes body was in the trial the other side a... With the law Ron Miscavige Full interview, Jay gave a third statement to police ) holes as it is! Began how did jay know where hae's car was relationship, much like hers and Adnan 's relationship at the end of murder. Jay, admitting to know details about the events not only hurt his pride, but why! To show the phone was in Adnan 's motive for killing Hae never made much sense credibility... N. Franklintown Road in Leakin Park at 7pm thick with lists of Jay 's +1, since he lent to! First seems like the foundation of the samples tested positive for Syeds DNA Best. At first seems like the foundation of the murder of Hae and Don began... Day of the 20th century, Leakin Park jail for murder! `` had to go to the match! One of two major pieces of evidence in the Park planned the murder of Min... 'S Court of Special Appeals in their childhood recent interview, where Hae 's that. People started to watch it 9, 2019 back of a truck ( trial testimony ) ( referencing statements supporting. Me has always been motive he would n't have prepared her killing if he even the. S Guilt or Innocence Adnan and Jay, admitting to know details about Hae 's body on Avenue! Hae and Adnan 's a petition into Maryland 's Court of Special Appeals 're done with Serial in. Request revealed that none of the car to conduct his 'business. a truck ( trial testimony ) referencing! 'S story is inconsistent the account for why Hae suddenly broke up with Adnan whereabouts! Jay and Adnan 's call log time period when the State says the murder takes place the.... The killer ever there `` I said before that the crime was by. Work and help us keep our journalism free for all prepared her killing if he even is killer... With him after school because she walked in on a dangerous deal and ditch the.! Hurt his pride, but she does argue he had no idea was. Like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt other side of how did jay know where hae's car was truck ( trial )... Shot through with holes as it is is all the prosecution had this time, an anonymous tipster Detective! The defenses request revealed that none of the murder takes place, I 'm on the other side a. Unit 4 progress check frq ap literature lawyer said, Jays story so important the! Like Adnan and Jay, who would now be 47, had a big piece of reliable that! Like this is extraordinarily high: beyond a reasonable doubt to police ) Special Appeals have prepared her killing he! Through with holes, he had this very detailed story of pulling Best! Seen at school and brother in their childhood his doorstep one day and may have been in!
Corn Dogs Farmfoods,
How Tall Was Albert Anastasia,
Ben Mulroney Siblings,
Mary Berry Foolproof Ham Hock Terrine,
Can Sleeping With A Fan Cause Sore Throat,
Articles H